How to Identify Your Core Values From Everyday Experiences

To identify your core values, write down two everyday experiences: one you made time for and one you wished you could make time for. Ask yourself what mattered in each. Choose a word that describes the reason, then write what that word means in your own life.

For example, “creativity” might mean making something with care even when nobody will see it. Check the definition against another experience. What still fits when you are tired, pressed for time, or doing the activity for someone else?

Morgan and the experiences below are fictional. Use the worked example to draft a definition on paper or in your notes.

AI-assisted editorial writing and review. Examples are fictional.

Begin with events, not a list of virtues

Write down two or three small experiences you are comfortable discussing. Describe what happened and what mattered to you. You do not need your whole life story, private messages or other people's identifying details.

Try including an experience where your actions did not match what you wanted. That makes room for a distinction a values list can miss: what you care about and what you had the opportunity to do.

For example, Morgan writes:

  • A missed activity: “I wanted to take a ceramics course, but the last bus home left before it finished. I didn't enroll. I still wish the timing had worked.”
  • Something worth the effort: “I spent a quiet afternoon making a birthday card. I enjoyed choosing the colors and getting the details right. I would have enjoyed making it even without a special occasion.”
  • A recurring commitment: “I help set up a neighborhood board-game evening. I like knowing what I'm responsible for and doing the part I agreed to do.”

None of these observations settles Morgan's values on its own. Missing the course does not establish that creativity is unimportant. Helping regularly does not tell us whether Morgan most values dependability, friendship, enjoyment, or something else.

The University of Wisconsin's values handout offers exercises for noticing what matters and where it is hard to act on it. Use that distinction here: a constraint belongs in the explanation, rather than disappearing behind a label.

Work through competing explanations

Morgan starts with three guesses: adventure because of the ceramics course, generosity because of the card, and sociability because of the game evening.

Those are possibilities, but the descriptions leave questions open. The next step is to ask what Morgan meant, rather than polishing those three labels.

ExperiencePossible interpretationDetail still needed
Wanted the ceramics courseEnjoys novelty or making thingsWas the attraction trying something unfamiliar, working with the material, meeting people, or another reason?
Made the card carefullyValues generosity or creative expressionWhich part mattered: giving it, making it, or both?
Helps with the game eveningValues sociability or dependabilityWhat feels worthwhile about the role?

Morgan might answer:

“I want to make things with my hands. I would enjoy repeating the same technique until I got better at it; I don't need a new activity every week. With the card, I liked both making it and giving it. At the games evening, I enjoy seeing people, but I especially care about doing what I said I'd do.”

That explanation changes the working list. “Adventure” now seems less useful to Morgan than “creativity.” “Generosity” remains possible, but the single card does not resolve how important it is across other situations. “Dependability” is a name Morgan wants to keep exploring.

What Morgan changes in their notes:

I'll keep creativity as a possible value and take adventure off my list for now. I haven't said I dislike new experiences; I just don't think novelty describes what mattered in this example. Leave generosity open rather than treating the card as proof.

Removing a label does not establish its opposite. Morgan has not discovered that they are unadventurous. They have decided that the available example does not support using adventure in this particular description.

Write what each value means to you

Start with “For me, [value] means [something I can recognize in an ordinary week].” Then add one thing the value leaves room for. Write it in words you would use with someone who knows you.

Morgan's completed sheet could look like this:

Working valueMy definitionWhat it does not requireAn example I can recognize
CreativityTaking care over something I make and having room to shape it myselfConstant novelty, public recognition, or being good at it immediatelySpending an afternoon choosing and arranging a card's colors
DependabilityBeing clear about what I agree to do and following through on that agreementBeing available for every requestCompleting the setup task I accepted for the game evening

The limits make the words more usable. Without them, “creativity” might turn into pressure to try new activities constantly, and “dependability” might become an obligation to accept every request.

For your own definition, ask:

If someone acted on this sentence literally, would they understand what I mean? Which words would I change?

Then try one contrasting example. Morgan could be dependable while declining an extra setup shift, provided they had not already promised to take it. That does not prove a general rule about every commitment; it clarifies the meaning Morgan chose for this sheet.

You do not have to finish with five values, or even two. One definition that you can explain is a complete starting point. You may also write “not sure yet” beside a candidate and stop there.

Keep constraints separate when values seem to conflict

Suppose Morgan later has an afternoon available for making something, but it overlaps with a setup shift they already accepted. This time, two personally important activities may compete. That is different from the original course, where transport made attendance impractical.

Before asking which value should “win,” describe the actual situation: what has been promised, what can move, and what options exist. You can record a temporary priority without asking a chatbot to rank creativity against dependability for your whole life.

Likewise, an empty calendar entry is not enough evidence that a stated value is false. Check what prevented the activity and whether you still wanted it. The answer may reveal a practical obstacle, a changed preference, a competing priority, or uncertainty. Leave those possibilities open until you can explain them.

Save a definition you can revisit

Copy this short sheet into your own notes:

  • A value name I choose:
  • What I mean by it:
  • An experience that helps explain it:
  • Another possible explanation for that experience:
  • A limit: this value does not require me to…
  • Something I still do not know:
  • An ordinary situation in which I could notice it next:

For Morgan, the last line might be: “When I next make a card, notice whether choosing the details still matters when I'm short on time.” It is an observation to make, not a test they can fail.

Keep the definitions you can explain. If the next example tells a different story, revise the wording or leave the question open.

Optional: talk through the reasons

The exercise works in your own notes. If you choose to explore your reasons in a chat, ask it to keep the experiences separate from any suggested labels:

Help me put my personal values into my own words. Start by asking about the reasons behind the experiences I describe, one question at a time. Keep what I wanted, what I did, and what limited my options separate. Suggest possible value names only after I have explained the reasons. For each name, show the detail that supports it and an alternative explanation. Let me reject or rename every suggestion. Do not rank my character or treat this as a personality test. Finish with definitions I have approved and any questions still open.

You can begin with just one experience if that feels easier. If the reply immediately produces ten values, ask it to return to the reasons. More labels do not necessarily give you more usable language.

A prompt is a request, not a guarantee that the chatbot will follow the method. Read its interpretation before accepting it. If the conversation feels like more work than the exercise itself, continue in your own notes.

You can also see how reflective conversation works in Clarify. If you’re starting with a page of mixed thoughts, the brain dump sorting guide can help you pick one experience to explore.